so i just got done making a response
video to Riley yesterday then i find
this load of bullshit i know there are
people who don't think being transgender
is a thing and this video is not for
them this video is for the people who
say yes trans women are women but they
are still biologically male let me guess
you have a problem with this
well alright perhaps you know something
that I don't
maybe just maybe rally know something
that I don't
so let's see what he has to say maybe
I'll learn something I learned how
fucking crazy Riley is because while
their intentions might be good
the impact that these words have is
actually very harmful I really don't see
how the intentions behind the statement
is anything other than an observation
with no malice or benevolence intended
trans women are not mail in saying that
they are allow some people to justify
the mistreatment of trans people i don't
think that you read this out before you
recorded this video what you're implying
with the statement is that men are more
likely to be mistreated than women now
if you have also said that trans men are
not female you would have a boy is this
mistake
are you also saying that trans men are
female I realized that this is
speculation but Riley doesn't talk about
transmitted at all in this video funny
that is transverse andrey cool now too
so i'm going to assume that you already
really believe that trans women are
women
yeah i agree with the statement but not
to the same absolute degree that you
want me to believe it i consider a trans
woman to be someone who was born a male
and has decided to undergo the process
to transition from a male to a female
but we cannot engage in large-scale
genetic re-engineering or performing
hair transplant from a male body to a
female body to create someone who's
completely female in this case no doubt
technology will get us there some day
but today is not that day rightly if you
don't believe that this video isn't
meant to convince you good thing because
you couldn't convince you that rain is
wet
maybe instead of leaving a recombinant
you go do some research into what it
means to be transgender that sounds like
a great idea Riley I think you should do
some research because you don't see my
butt fucking clue
I'll leave some links in the description
some very good resources to get you
started
oh great Riley is now the tranny Pope
all have the new tranny Pope alright so
let's say that you're trying to be a
good Ally
the trans people and you heard that sex
and gender are two different things
sex is biological and gender is a social
construct that's not entirely true
is this real is Riley really going down
this road now science is a social
construct that's not exactly what Riley
is saying but it might as well be
yeah all of science can be thrown out of
the window because feelings
let's commence the book burnings sex and
gender are two different things but
they're both partly social constructs
just in different ways now would be a
great time to fly into a window for a
long time gender has been assigned to
people based on their perceived sex a
doctor looks at the babies genitals and
determines what gender it will be raised
as though the ever so oppressive gender
assignments
it's not a gender assignment you idiot
it's a gender observation
do you realize that they can actually
tell what gender of baby is going to be
before it's even born my god it looks
like there are differences between males
and females in our culture that used to
be unquestionable fact they're like
unquestionable observation
it's like saying this car is red there
is no questioning here there is nothing
to question what you want to argue with
me and say this car is painted in poppy
flowers do you hear yourself college you
brainwashed you were raised as the
gender you are assigned at birth and
being transgender wasn't an option
probably because the technology to
change gender didn't exist until very
recently dumbass it doesn't mean that
trans people didn't exist we've existed
as long as humans have existed they have
always existed in me but being
transgender was not a mainstream topic
of discussion today many of us recognize
that gender is far more complicated than
a person's perceived sex and were able
to acknowledge that people can be
transgender gender was a social
construct before and still is now
citation fries but how we construct it
has changed now we can say that your
gender is based on how you identify
because we realize that basic gender on
proceed sex was oppressive exactly how
was it oppressive Riley just feeling out
bullshit doesn't make it true
again I'm not really talking about
society at large because a lot of people
still don't fully understand what it
means to be transgender but I mean
within trans accepting communities
however even within these communities
binary sex has for some reason chuckles
as the same kind of unquestionable fact
that we used to think gender was you
don't say and what you think that is
Riley couldn't be the only point zero
three percent of the population is trans
no that's crazy talk
I've made a video before about intersex
conditions and how sex isn't a perfect
binary but for now let's just talk about
what it means to be male or female
because i would argue that sex me to go
through the same change the gender has
already gone through
yes social justice needs to infect
science even more to make it more
inclusive where's the window when you
needed
it's not a static fact it's a social
constructs i'm still waiting for that
citation Riley you can't say something
as the social contract without providing
evidence
I'm sure that some people are having
this major cree action that sex is based
on biology and you can't change a
person's biology but that's exactly what
we used to say about Jen but what you're
talking about is unnatural Riley yeah
a man can become a woman and vice versa
but you can't do it naturally you idiot
some animals can yes but not human there
was a way of categorizing humans based
on a combination of a few traits
chromosomes genitals gonads hormones and
secondary sex characteristics like
facial hair or breast development most
people never have their chromosomes
tested they're not tested at birth and
they're not tested a regular checkup
unless your doctor suspect that
something might be wrong with your
chromosomes that you'll probably never
have been tested in your life and you
certainly can't tell a person's
chromosomes by looking at the hormones
are also not visible without a test and
genitals and gonads are usually not
visible most of the time so the way that
most people have determining someone sex
it's simply their secondary sex
characteristics that developed computer
before puberty children with penises and
children with vaginas are really not
that different you you can't even say
girls and boys is that what you call
prepubescent children
Riley you call them children with
penises and children listen ginaz you're
probably going to be questioned by the
police about this someday
just give me a heads up there I do care
about you you provide me with endless
entertainment
it's the rush of hormones around puberty
that begins to develop the secondary sex
characteristics people with penises and
to develop facial hair gain muscle mass
and get a deeper voice people with
vaginas tend to develop breasts get
wider hips and
more subcutaneous fat but these are not
perfect differentiators affect some
people with penises don't develop much
any facial hair while some develop beard
and the amount of facial hair that they
have doesn't make them more or less male
the same goes for people with vaginas
some of them will develop large breasts
some of them will develop small breasts
but neither of those is more or less
female
you might want to stop calling men
people with penises and women people
with vaginas if you're this focused on
what people have between their legs it's
no wonder you're such a freak show
there's a lot of overlap between these
characteristics some people with vaginas
will have deeper voices than some people
with penises and some people with
penises will be shorter than some people
with vaginas it's not like all people
with penises fit into one box at all
people with vaginas fit into another box
it's like they're all in the same box
but people with penises tend to hang out
one size and people with vaginas tend to
hang out on the up it's almost as you're
describing how people socialize in high
school and how they fucking high school
plus all of these secondary sex
characteristics can be changed either
through hormones or serger true they can
but you're taking something and changing
it from how it was meant to naturally
develop when people find female I
birthday testosterone they can get
deeper voices and grow more facial hair
while people assigned male at birth can
take estrogen and develop breasts and
more subcutaneous fat and the puberty
blockers are taken before hormones a
person to find female ever might never
experienced a female needle puberty or
vice versa for people assigned male at
birth so the sexy were assigned at Birth
doesn't necessarily tell you what
secondary sex characteristics you'll
have later in life that means that
telling someone you know their sex based
on their secondary sex characteristics
is just not true
do you understand the words that just
came out of your mouth do you speak
English
I'm serious this is a serious question
is english language that you speak on a
day-to-day basis
I know you speak French as well and
you're definitely not speaking she act
which is a bachelor ization of the two
at least in my neck of the woods
you're clearly not understanding what
you're also saying here Riley you're
saying that without picking hormones
girls and boys grow up to be women and
then but you still think you can tell
someone sex based on their genitals or
going as well genitals can be changed
with surgery some people assigned male
at birth have vaginas
through surgery called vaginoplasty some
people find female at Birth have penises
thanks to surgery called follow plastic
to follow that makes you want to close
my legs and stop man spreading in my
house alone I guess even in the privacy
of my own home
I still can't stop oppressing women so
genitals aren't a great indicator and
gonads so ovaries or testes are often
removed in the case of testicular or
ovarian cancer but if a woman has their
ovaries removed due to cancer if you no
longer female if a man has the st
germain due to cancer is he no longer
mail i don't think so i would have been
more firm said no they don't stop being
male or female but congrats Riley you
finally said something that doesn't make
you sound like a fucking idiot and I
don't think you can say that gonads to
find a person sex without believing that
back to sound like a fucking idiot so
out of the five ways we have of
determining someone sex four of those
five hormones secondary sex
characteristics genitals and Gomez
cannot be accurately used to determine
someone sex is there any shred of sanity
left in your head
Riley I mean I'm definitely seeing his
personal planets but you if you are an
alien that seems human form I think that
would make more sense for example if
someone was assigned male at birth but
took puberty blockers and hormones and
had a vaginoplasty they have female
hormones secondary sex characteristics
and gentle so three of the five ways of
determining sex would be female wouldn't
have male or female don't ads at that
point and let's assume their chromosomes
are XY that means that three-fifths of
the sexes criteria point2 female and
only 150 points to mail and if you
believe that sex is an unchanging
biological fact that could be possible
but it is here's where people say well
you can't change your chromosome and
yeah that's correct but if you want to
argue that sex is entirely determined by
chromosomes then you're arguing against
the definition of what we call
biological sex because sex has never
been only about chromosomes it's been
about all five of these traits and tell
me what good is dividing people based on
their chromosomes do it comes don't
determine your hormones secondary sex
characteristics genitals or gonads what
purpose do they serve in differentiating
people it helps you the fun and made
that you find desirable inmate that you
can have children with and pass on your
genes which is a biological urge we all
have and is critical to the survival of
our species
you do realize that we evolved on this
planet Riley but if I didn't know any
better I would say your feminist
creationist yes there is
they served no purpose there's no reason
to divide XX people & XY people that is
an arbitrary distinction that has no
effect on how the person looks or
behaves or navigate the world you can't
know someone's chromosomes by looking at
them and even if you could it wouldn't
give you any useful information about
the person that's the point I'm trying
to make sex is not a biological fact
because it is determined by things that
are largely changeable and the only part
of it that is unchangeable doesn't have
any real-world effects so it is just as
much a social construct as gender is
ensure your feminist congregation is
loving this sermon but i'm not saying
that for a trans person to be trans they
have to have all the surgeries and take
all the hormones the trans person is
trans if they claim that identity
because this person doesn't become
transformed i have their ovaries removed
due to cancer and a trans person is
assist just because they can't afford
hormones having a vagina doesn't make
you a female regardless of whether you
were born with it or got it through
surgery wondering about your identity
and therefore so expect the fact that
sex is so fluid means that thinking of
sex as a binary unmoving fact of life is
just wrong
listen and believe listen and believe so
if you like transwoman your female if
you're trans man your mail and if you're
either a man nor woman then you're
neither male nor female biological sex
have to undergo the same paradigm shift
is a gender did continue with that bird
because science hurts our feelings we
need to start thinking about it as a
social construct rather than in arguable
fact because when people say that a
trans woman is biologically male they
use that as a way to attack trans people
use it as an excuse to exclude us from
bathrooms and locker rooms and other
women spaces
something tells me that Riley is making
this video because the women's only gym
he tried to sign up for through his ass
to the curb as they should
you know it's okay you're just a lesbian
with up unit so it's fine if i get a
boner by looking at other women in the
gym it's just a more subtle and more
socially acceptable way of
discriminating against trans people you
might mean well by saying that sex and
gender are two different things but I
think it's important to emphasize that
both our social constructs based on your
identity
well I wasted a good chunk of my day
making this video now I want to drink
bleach
No comments:
Post a Comment